Saturday, July 17, 2010

A People "Suffer" First Government?

The Prime Minister must prove to the rakyat that the “people first” slogan is not about increasing taxes and price, while reducing subsidies to the people first.

We would like to express our complete disappointment with the unequal actions taken by the Barisan Nasional government for prioritising the subsidies to the rakyat as the first expenditure to be cut as a result of fiscal deficits caused by the government's irresponsible and wasteful expenditures over the past decade.

We agree that some of the subsidies to the rakyat needs to be rationalised to ensure that the poor and needy receive a greater proportion of the benefits than the wealthy. However, the above should not be used as an excuse to victimise the people first without first taking concrete and visible actions to cut subsidies to large politically-connected companies or bloated expenditures for price-inflated projects.

The Prime Minister claims that even after the latest subsidy cuts, the government will still spend RM7.82 billion for fuel and food subsidies. However he fails to highlight the fact that Petronas will continue to provide subsidies to Tenaga Nasional (TNB), the independent power producers (IPPs) and the industrial sector, which was RM18.9 billion for its financial year ending March 2010.

Out of this amount, more than 40% or nearly RM8 billion goes to the IPPs. Unfortunately, most of the subsidies to the IPPs do not translate into lower prices of electricity for the users due to the unequal and unfair agreements which TNB was forced to sign with the IPPs. TNB has to not only purchase electricity from IPPs at prices much higher than what it could produce on its own, but it has also to pay for the total capacity of these IPPs, regardless of whether there is a demand or otherwise. Hence, there is an excess capacity as high as 50% today which is completely which has resulted in heavy subsidies for the IPPs, high prices of electricity for the users and massive profits for the IPPs.

The question to the government is, given the financial constraints that the government is facing, why isn't the government targetting the fat cats which are lynching off the tax-payers' hard-earned monies first, before attacking the livelihood of ordinary Malaysians?

The Government has also failed in other means to save money for the rakyat by continuing the practice of direct negotiations for large-scale privatisation contracts which often results in substantially higher prices and higher risk of project failure or further increases in cost. For example, the Government awarded the contract to build Malaysia's largest exhibition and convention centre at the cost of RM628 million to Naza TTDI Sdn Bhd without any tender, open or closed. The government has also awarded a 20-year, interest-free, unsecured and back-loaded RM320 loan to Syarikat Bekalan Air Selangor (SYABAS), a private company which will cost tax-payers more than RM250 million in interest.

The Government's lack of political will to tackle corporate subsidies and opaque procurement processes to politically-connected companies demonstrate without a doubt that it is failing to live up to the Prime Minister's slogan on “people first”, but has instead made the people the first to suffer from the Government's transgressions, incompetence and a serious lack of accountability.


Samuel Goh Kim Eng said...


When you can't "call a spade a spade"
You are trying to hide truth in the shade
Which is located not too far away from hade
Useless then to comment on people in various grades

(C) Samuel Goh Kim Eng - 170710
Sat. 17th July 2010.

Anonymous said...

When going after this guy, you really need to plan well. His respond when he is wrong is to shut up and not answer. He has never answered the controversy he was involved in while MB Johor - the land deals, the water deals etc. - not even Mahathir saying he is the richest man in UMNO.

alvin said...


Can anyone from SPRM also explain why is there a 1Malaysia logo on their website?

Isn't SPRM supposed to be "neutral"?

Oh yeah, I had forgotten they are supposed to "neutralize" others.

That much we speak of neutrality. That is why 1Malaysia is a People "Suffer" First slogan.

I support your comprehension of the 1Malaysia concept!!

Samuel Goh Kim Eng said...


Any price hikes on any popular or essential items
Will definitely have spiral effects on related goods
Most visible ones being increased prices on various foods
Bearing in mind that any changes to the roots will affect the stems

(C) Samuel Goh Kim Eng - 180710
Sun. 18th July 2010.

Anonymous said...

Yes, a big chunk of fuel subsidy goes to IPPs and industrial big boys. Politically, it is easy to ketuk the BN Govt but - in reality, subsidies to IPPs cannot be chopped just like that...that are implications to bond-holders, FIs and foreign/local investors.

The subsidy to IPPs was a legacy mistake left from Mamakthir days - your eyes will pop out if you know how much YTL/YTL Power make from its PPA signed in 1993 during Mamakthir days...the obscene profit (at the expense of rakyat/taxpayer) that is almost riskless with really one-sided clauses (side with you know who).